Sialor and Protargol have good reviews, but also negative ones. There are representatives who are of the opinion that due to the fact that silver ions are toxic, it is dangerous to use these drugs. However, there is no research evidence of the dangers of drugs – only speculation. The main thing is to follow the instructions and apply them only for the intended purpose and strict prescription of a specialist.
The issue of appointment can be solved by individual intolerance to one of the drugs.
Nasal congestion causes a lot of problems. It is impossible to do anything when there is not enough air all the time and you have to breathe through your mouth. In such situations, you can apply nasal drops, which contribute to relieve swelling and reduce inflammation in the nasal mucosa. Most often, doctors prescribe Sialor or Protargol. Which one is more efficient and more reliable?
In each case, it is possible to prescribe one or another drug:
- Because of its convenience, Sialor is prescribed more often than Protargol. After all, you can cook the first yourself.
- For those who do not use drops, Sialor spray is suitable.
- People with weakened immunity will be prescribed a milder Sialor.
- With a combination of rhinitis with other ENT diseases, Protargol will be prescribed.
- When working requiring precise care, Protargol will not be prescribed (due to possible drowsiness).
- Sialor will be prescribed in order to prevent diseases of the nasolacrimal canal.
- If it is impossible to instill frequently, it is better to use Protargol.
Sialor and Protargol consist of the same active substance – colloidal silver. Even in ancient times, this metal was used as a fight against infectious diseases. Medicines containing its particles were used in treatment until antibiotics appeared. Colloidal silver has regulatory approval as an antibacterial antimicrobial agent. Few doctors and researchers agree with this, but, nevertheless, it is still used in medicine.
In fact, Sialor and Protargol are analogues. However, some differences affect the choice of one of them. What are they? And when and what to use?
Sialor
Sialor is an anti-inflammatory, antiseptic drug containing silver proteinate. It has an astringent and disinfecting effect. Silver ions resist the entry of bacteria and microbes into the nasal mucosa and skin, inhibiting their reproduction. The medicine stimulates the restoration of immunity.
Indications for appointment:
- Rhinitis (inflammatory and allergic).
- Sinusitis, frontal sinusitis.
- Adenoids.
- Prevention after surgery.
- Chronic pathology of the mucosa.
- Hygienic procedures for the nose in children and adults.
The medicine can be used for prevention in the winter-autumn period, with a change in the climatic environment and poor environmental conditions. Rarely, when it is used, itching and burning of the nasal mucosa can occur.
Release Forms:
- Tablets for the preparation of a 200 mg solution in a package with a dropper bottle or dispenser.
- Drops Sialor (Protargol) in a bottle with a dropper 10 ml
- Drops Sialor Aqua (with sea water) in a bottle with a dropper 10 ml.
- Drops (spray) Sialor (Protargol) in a bottle with a dispenser-spray 10 ml.
The dosage depends on age and ranges from 1-2 drops to 8 times a day.
Contraindications:
- Individual intolerance to the components.
- The combination of drugs containing alkaloids and organic bases.
Use with caution during pregnancy and lactation. The medicine is dispensed from pharmacies without a prescription.
Protargol
Protargol is a drug containing colloidal silver. Relieves inflammation, has an antiseptic and astringent effect. Suppresses the spread of infection. It is used in ophthalmology, otolaryngology and urology.
Indications for appointment:
- Rhinitis (inflammatory or allergic).
- Adenoids.
- Conjunctivitis.
- Pharyngitis.
- Otitis.
- Cystitis, urethritis.
It does not fight viruses, therefore, before use, you need to consult a doctor to find out the cause of the disease. May cause an allergic reaction: itching, burning and dryness in the nasal mucosa. Rarely, headache and drowsiness.
Release Forms:
- Powder for the preparation of a solution of 1% in 10 ml (only on order)
- Tablets for the preparation of a solution of 2% in 10 ml.
Due to the low toxicity of the drug, children are recommended to use only a 1% solution. The dosage depends on the age of the patient and ranges from 1-3 drops to 3 times in knocking.
Contraindications:
- Individual intolerance to the components.
- Pregnancy and lactation.
It is not recommended to be combined with medicines containing papain (for example, it is present in whitening toothpaste). Doctors recommend that you strictly follow the instructions and do not take it for more than the specified period and dosage. Released by prescription.
Similarities of funds
Sialor and Protargol are analogues. They contain the same active substance. Therefore, they have many similarities:
- They struggle with similar diseases.
- They have an antiseptic, anti-inflammatory and astringent effect.
- Applicable in childhood.
- Allowed to pregnant and lactating women only under the supervision of a doctor.
- They have similar contraindications.
- They can not be taken more than the prescribed period – strictly according to the prescription.
Differences Means
Despite the similarity in composition, they have some differences:
- Sialor is considered a means of a new generation, and Protargol is an old one. The first can be purchased at the pharmacy yourself, while the second is made to order.
- Protargol is available only with a prescription. At home, it is almost impossible to cook.
- Sialor has a longer shelf life – after cooking no more than 30 days, and when closed, 2 years. Protargol in finished form should be stored no more than 14 days, and in closed form – no more than 2 years.
- Sialor has more convenient forms of release, then Protargol is inferior in this, and it may require an additional purchase – a pipette.
- Protargol has a larger list of side effects.
- Protargol has a wider list of the fight against inflammatory and infectious diseases.
- Sialor can be used for prophylaxis, while its counterpart is not.
- Protargol does not need frequent instillation ( up to 3 times a day ), while Sialor in a larger amount ( up to 8 times a day ).
- Sialor will be a little more expensive.
